Jul 26, 2017

Eat Curd, say No to Yakult



Honestly, I hadn’t researched much about this probiotic/prebiotic craze until a couple of friends pointed out that Kefir and Kombucha are rising in popularity. Let’s begin with a teeny tiny summary before we talk about Yakult.

Probiotics are good bacteria that keeps your digestive system healthy by controlling growth of harmful bacteria. They help the intestines break down food. They boost our immunity, lowers the risk of colon cancer and increases the effectiveness of vitamins.

Prebiotics are food for probiotics. They are made up of carbohydrates that your body can’t digest. They reach the large intestine without getting affected by the digestion process. Prebiotics such as fructooligosaccharides (FOS) and galacto‐oligosaccharides (GOS) are naturally found in many foods such as whole wheat, onion, garlic, cabbage, legumes etc.

Now, let’s talk about probiotics in more detail:

Probiotics bacteria belong to the two families of bacteria:
Strains of Lactobacillus and Bifidobacterium are both associated with probiotic formulas 

One of the best sources of probiotics is yoghurt. Pickles are also a great source. Fermentation process helps in producing probiotics. 

Probiotics foods that are gaining popularity are
- Kefir (fermented milk drink made with kefir grains), 
- Kimchi (made with fermented vegetables), 
- Sauerkraut (made with fermented cabbage),
- Kombucha (fermented yeast tea), 
- sourdough bread etc

Probiotics are also available in the form of supplements that contain “live” bacteria. The important thing to keep in mind is that probiotics supplements aren’t regulated according to "drug standards" by the US FDA. There are chances of developing allergic reactions to the new bacteria being added to your body. Also, one needs to be careful when giving probiotics supplements to children under the age of 12.

Coming to Yakult, it is a fermented milk drink that contains 6.5 billion probiotics called LcS (L-casei Shirota). LcS is Yakult’s exclusive probiotic strain. 

It comes in a pack of 5 plastic bottles with a price tag of Rs.60. Each bottle of 65 ml is therefore priced at Rs.12. Recommended serving is 1-2 bottles per day for all ages above 1 year.

I have only 2 issues with this product right now. Let’s keep aside the thought whether the “exclusive” LcS probiotic strain is effective or not. It will need more time to research about its effectiveness.


(1) High sugar
Let’s look at the ingredients list:
Water, Sugar, Skimmed Milk Powder, Glucose, Lactobacillus casei strain Shirota (LcS)

The nutritional facts table show that a single bottle (65 ml) contains 10 gm of added sugar, which means a whopping 2.5 tsp of sugar in each bottle.

(2) Single-use plastic
Why? Seriously why? To keep our guts clean, why do we need to pollute our planet? If a family of 3 drinks Yakult on a daily basis, how many plastic bottles will be disposed in a week, in a month and in a year? New-product innovators need to think hard, not just about their profitability and growth but also on the trash they leave behind on the planet.

As I was googling about Yakult and LcS, I stumbled upon this brilliant article - 11 reasons to avoid Yakult and other probiotic drinks. Is there anything more to be said?

Gut health is a “hot topic” these days. We have spoilt our gut flora (good bacteria) so much that we are looking for external, artificial quick fixes. 

How did we spoil our gut flora in the first place?
- Excessive use of over-the-counter painkillers and antibiotics
- Excess stress
- Drinking too much alcohol
- Lack of Physical activity
- Smoking cigarettes
- Not getting enough sleep
- Not eating adequate foods that contain prebiotics
- and many more reasons

Our ancestors never had to worry about probiotics. 

In South India, we use fermented batters all the time - idli, dosa, aapam etc. But what kind of breakfasts do we have these days - corn flakes, chocos, oats and what not?

In Tamilnadu especially in villages, people used to eat “pazhayadhu” (cooked rice fermented overnight) and kambankali (cooked pearl millet balls fermented overnight). These practices don’t sound attractive but we’ll go and pay a huge price for fancy names like kefir, kombucha etc. 15 gms of Kefir grains cost Rs.650 (source)

There are a huge variety of pickles that are made all over India. But we fear the oil and salt and instead, embrace sugar-laden probiotic supplements sold in plastic bottles. 

It used to be a daily practice to set curd at home. Now we have started to rely on packaged yoghurt, more so the “slim" version sold in plastic bags and containers.

Unless we start to appreciate our country’s food traditions and practices, there will always be new “hot topics” introduced, along with fancy new solutions that come with a premium price tag.
Do we need products like Yakult in the first place? Aren't we only treating the symptoms and not addressing the main issues?

As for me, I’m content with my everyday “thachi mammu” (curd rice), idli/dosas made with homemade fermented batters and of course, pickles. And adequate lentils and vegetables to feed my gut flora.

Sources:

6 comments:

Prateeksha Keshari said...

Very balanced and enlightening thoughts Anuradha!

Unknown said...

Good article Anuradha. My family too are Thachi mammu fans. But our pickles are not probiotic sources. They are not fermented pickles.

Unknown said...

I agree.

Sameer Alam said...

I cycle LifeWay's Kefir and Yakult. Our daily curd is no match to it.
If you wish to discuss further, happy to get into ingredient details and the mechanisms of these different products vs the ones that you mentioned.

Both Yakult and Kefir have helped me IMMENSELY with IBS, chronic digestion issues that other medicine failed to fix. For me it's a life saving elixir. I maintain a very healthy and active lifestyle that includes working out for over 8hrs a week and eating balanced meals that includes lots of protein, veggies and healthy fats.

I request everyone to do a thorough research before publishing such articles. PLEASS.#Responsibility.

Sameer Alam said...

I do agree with the claims of added sugar and the plastic waste that it generates.

However, when publishing articles, both sides must be represented without bias. Yakult is also one of the few big companies that support women by employing only women for their delivery system.

Thanks

Anuradha Sridharan said...

@Sameer Alam, as I have mentioned in my post, I have highlighted the two main issues with Yakult - high sugar and single use plastic. These two issues are important enough reasons for a conscious individual like me. Yes, Yakult might provide employment opportunities to women (as do so many junk food makers). But would I want to put my health and my family's health at stake, just so people are getting employment?
Please talk about responsibility to these brands first, who are spoiling the health of our generation as well as that of the planet's well being. On Kefir, it might have helped you but it is not affordable for everyone. That's exactly what I have mentioned. I haven't questioned the efficacy of such probiotics. Please read the article fully.

Get the latest posts by email

Blog Archive

All contents copyrighted by Anuradha Sridharan, 2019. Don't copy without giving credits. Powered by Blogger.